--- title: "Choosing the Right ATS: What to Evaluate Before Making a Decision" description: Before you pick an ATS, know what to evaluate. A clear guide to configurability, compliance, integration, and total cost. --- [Skip to content](https://www.graylink.biz/blog/choosing-the-right-ats-what-to-evaluate-before-making-a-decision#main-content) [![reccruitment software](https://www.graylink.biz/hs-fs/hubfs/graylink_logo_vector_colour.png?width=230&height=85&name=graylink_logo_vector_colour.png)](https://25214134.hs-sites-eu1.com/) - [Products](https://www.graylink.biz/products) Show submenu for Products - [Neptune](https://www.graylink.biz/neptune-cloud-software-for-enterprise-recruitment-management) - [txthr](https://www.graylink.biz/chatbots-to-automate-recruitment-and-talent-processes) Show submenu for txthr - [Hire](https://www.graylink.biz/chatbots-to-automate-recruitment-and-talent-processes_1) - [Refer](https://www.graylink.biz/employee-referrals-with-txtrefer) - [Solutions](https://www.graylink.biz/digital-talent-solutions) Show submenu for Solutions - [Industry](https://www.graylink.biz/digital-talent-solutions) Show submenu for Industry - [Retail](https://www.graylink.biz/retail-recruiting-with-automated-recruitment-chatbots) - [Financial Services](https://www.graylink.biz/financial-services-recruiting-with-automated-recruitment-chatbots) - [Mining & Energy](https://www.graylink.biz/mining-energy-recruiting-with-automated-recruitment-chatbots) - [FMCG](https://www.graylink.biz/fmcg-recruitment-software-graylink) - [Hospitality](https://www.graylink.biz/hospitality-recruitment-software) - [Logistics & Fleet](https://www.graylink.biz/logistics-transport-recruitment-software-graylink) - [BPO & Call Centre](https://www.graylink.biz/call-centre-recruitment) - [Manufacturing](https://www.graylink.biz/manufacturing-recruitment-software-graylink) - [Public Sector](https://www.graylink.biz/public-sector-recruiting-with-automated-recruitment-chatbots) - [Professional Services](https://www.graylink.biz/professional-services-recruitment-software-graylink) - [Academia & Higher Ed](https://www.graylink.biz/academia-higher-education-recruitment-software-graylink) - [Healthcare & Pharma](https://www.graylink.biz/healthcare-pharmaceutical-recruitment-software-graylink) - [Use Cases](https://www.graylink.biz/digital-talent-solutions) Show submenu for Use Cases - [Non-desk Recruitment](https://www.graylink.biz/non-desk-worker-recruitment-software-graylink) - [Learnership Recruitment](https://www.graylink.biz/learnership-recruitment) - [Graduate Recruitment](https://www.graylink.biz/graduate-recruiting-with-automated-recruitment-chatbots) - [Internship Recruitment](https://www.graylink.biz/internship-recruiting-with-automated-recruitment-chatbots) - [YES Programme](https://www.graylink.biz/yes-programme-recruiting-with-automated-recruitment-chatbots) - Challenges Show submenu for Challenges - [Talent Acquisition](https://www.graylink.biz/talent-sourcing-and-engagement) - [Process Automation](https://www.graylink.biz/recruitment-workflow-automations) - [Compliance Management](https://www.graylink.biz/recruitment-compliance-management) - [Reporting & Insights](https://www.graylink.biz/recruitment-reporting-insights) - [Data Exchange](https://www.graylink.biz/data-exchange-and-integrations) - Guides Show submenu for Guides - [Recruitment and AI](https://www.graylink.biz/ai-recruitment) - Connect Show submenu for Connect - [Contact](https://www.graylink.biz/contact) - [Join our team](https://www.graylink.biz/about#joinourteam) - [About us](https://www.graylink.biz/about) - [Blog](https://www.graylink.biz/blog) - [Get demo](https://www.graylink.biz/getdemo) Open main navigation Close main navigation - [Products](https://www.graylink.biz/products) Show submenu for Products - [Neptune](https://www.graylink.biz/neptune-cloud-software-for-enterprise-recruitment-management) - [txthr](https://www.graylink.biz/chatbots-to-automate-recruitment-and-talent-processes) Show submenu for txthr - [Hire](https://www.graylink.biz/chatbots-to-automate-recruitment-and-talent-processes_1) - [Refer](https://www.graylink.biz/employee-referrals-with-txtrefer) - [Solutions](https://www.graylink.biz/digital-talent-solutions) Show submenu for Solutions - [Industry](https://www.graylink.biz/digital-talent-solutions) Show submenu for Industry - [Retail](https://www.graylink.biz/retail-recruiting-with-automated-recruitment-chatbots) - [Financial Services](https://www.graylink.biz/financial-services-recruiting-with-automated-recruitment-chatbots) - [Mining & Energy](https://www.graylink.biz/mining-energy-recruiting-with-automated-recruitment-chatbots) - [FMCG](https://www.graylink.biz/fmcg-recruitment-software-graylink) - [Hospitality](https://www.graylink.biz/hospitality-recruitment-software) - [Logistics & Fleet](https://www.graylink.biz/logistics-transport-recruitment-software-graylink) - [BPO & Call Centre](https://www.graylink.biz/call-centre-recruitment) - [Manufacturing](https://www.graylink.biz/manufacturing-recruitment-software-graylink) - [Public Sector](https://www.graylink.biz/public-sector-recruiting-with-automated-recruitment-chatbots) - [Professional Services](https://www.graylink.biz/professional-services-recruitment-software-graylink) - [Academia & Higher Ed](https://www.graylink.biz/academia-higher-education-recruitment-software-graylink) - [Healthcare & Pharma](https://www.graylink.biz/healthcare-pharmaceutical-recruitment-software-graylink) - [Use Cases](https://www.graylink.biz/digital-talent-solutions) Show submenu for Use Cases - [Non-desk Recruitment](https://www.graylink.biz/non-desk-worker-recruitment-software-graylink) - [Learnership Recruitment](https://www.graylink.biz/learnership-recruitment) - [Graduate Recruitment](https://www.graylink.biz/graduate-recruiting-with-automated-recruitment-chatbots) - [Internship Recruitment](https://www.graylink.biz/internship-recruiting-with-automated-recruitment-chatbots) - [YES Programme](https://www.graylink.biz/yes-programme-recruiting-with-automated-recruitment-chatbots) - Challenges Show submenu for Challenges - [Talent Acquisition](https://www.graylink.biz/talent-sourcing-and-engagement) - [Process Automation](https://www.graylink.biz/recruitment-workflow-automations) - [Compliance Management](https://www.graylink.biz/recruitment-compliance-management) - [Reporting & Insights](https://www.graylink.biz/recruitment-reporting-insights) - [Data Exchange](https://www.graylink.biz/data-exchange-and-integrations) - Guides Show submenu for Guides - [Recruitment and AI](https://www.graylink.biz/ai-recruitment) - Connect Show submenu for Connect - [Contact](https://www.graylink.biz/contact) - [Join our team](https://www.graylink.biz/about#joinourteam) - [About us](https://www.graylink.biz/about) - [Blog](https://www.graylink.biz/blog) - [Get demo](https://www.graylink.biz/getdemo) 12 June, 2026 # Choosing the Right ATS: What to Evaluate Before Making a Decision ![Picture of Mark Gray](https://www.graylink.biz/hs-fs/hubfs/Mark-Gray-graylink.png?width=50&name=Mark-Gray-graylink.png) [Mark Gray](https://www.graylink.biz/blog/author/mark-gray) Share: [facebook-f icon](http://www.facebook.com/share.php?u=https://www.graylink.biz/blog/choosing-the-right-ats-what-to-evaluate-before-making-a-decision) [linkedin-in icon](http://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?mini=true&url=https://www.graylink.biz/blog/choosing-the-right-ats-what-to-evaluate-before-making-a-decision) [Twitter icon](https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?url=https://www.graylink.biz/blog/choosing-the-right-ats-what-to-evaluate-before-making-a-decision) [pinterest-p icon](http://pinterest.com/pin/create/link/?url=https://www.graylink.biz/blog/choosing-the-right-ats-what-to-evaluate-before-making-a-decision) [envelope icon](mailto:?body=https://www.graylink.biz/blog/choosing-the-right-ats-what-to-evaluate-before-making-a-decision) #### Overview - An applicant tracking system (ATS) is recruitment infrastructure your team will run on for years, so judge it on how it handles your real workflows rather than on demo polish. - For South African employers, **configurability and compliance** (POPIA and Employment Equity) should carry the most weight, followed by a **mobile-first candidate experience**. - Score each vendor against a **weighted scorecard**, test your own workflows in a sandbox and give recruiters a vote. - Compare vendors on **three-year total cost of ownership**, not the licence fee on the first invoice. [![txthr Demo](https://www.graylink.biz/hs-fs/hubfs/Pop%20up%20button%20(6)%201.png?width=1996&height=222&name=Pop%20up%20button%20(6)%201.png)](https://www.graylink.biz/chatbots-to-automate-recruitment-and-talent-processes) #### What should you evaluate before choosing an ATS? Evaluate nine areas: configurability, compliance, candidate experience, integration, automation, reporting, scalability, local support and total cost of ownership. The first three decide whether the system fits your business. The rest decide how well it performs once it is live. Most ATS decisions go wrong at the evaluation stage. Teams compare feature lists, sit through scripted demos and choose the platform that looks most impressive. Six months later, recruiters are working around the system instead of through it. The fix is to treat an ATS as part of your [HR infrastructure](https://www.graylink.biz/blog/saas-hr-infrastructure-a-modular-approach-to-recruitment) and test it under your own conditions. #### How should you weight each criterion? Weight configurability and compliance highest, and give AI features less weight than most buyers expect. AI capability changes every quarter and can be added later. A rigid workflow engine or a compliance gap is expensive to fix after go-live. This is the weighting we recommend for a South African enterprise ATS evaluation: | Criterion | Weight | | --- | --- | | Configurability | 20% | | Compliance (POPIA and EE) | 20% | | Candidate experience | 15% | | Integration | 10% | | Automation and AI | 10% | | Reporting and analytics | 10% | | Local support | 10% | | Scalability | 5% | Score each vendor from 1 to 5 per criterion and multiply by the weight. If you recruit at high volume (retail, contact centres, learnerships), move 5 to 10 points from integration and reporting to scalability. Keep total cost of ownership outside the scorecard. Compare it against each vendor's capability score at the end, so price does not distort how you judge fit. #### 1. Configurability: will the system fit your process? A [configurable ATS](https://www.graylink.biz/neptune-cloud-software-for-enterprise-recruitment-management) adapts to your approval chains, interview stages and user roles without vendor development work. A rigid one forces you to change your process to suit the software. Ask the vendor to build one of your real workflows in front of you, including approvals, interview stages and the offer process. If the answer involves a "development request" or "custom build", treat it as a warning. Configuration should sit with your administrators, not in a vendor's development queue. Key questions to ask: - Can workflows differ by division, region or role type? - Can our own administrators change workflows without vendor involvement? - How are permission levels and user roles managed? #### 2. Compliance: does it meet POPIA and Employment Equity requirements? Your ATS must capture candidate consent, store personal data securely and produce Employment Equity (EE) reports without manual spreadsheet work. In South Africa these are legal obligations, and global platforms often treat them as afterthoughts. The stakes rose in 2025. The Employment Equity Amendment Act took effect on 1 January 2025, and the Department of Employment and Labour [published five-year sector numerical EE targets](https://labourguide.co.za/employment-equity/other-related-ee/publication-of-the-two-sets-of-employment-equity-regulations-following-the-commencement-of-the-ee-amendment-act-no-4-of-2022) for 18 economic sectors that April. Designated employers now need clean demographic data from the application stage to track progress against those targets. If a vendor cannot show you how the platform supports [EE reporting](https://www.graylink.biz/blog/employment-equity-reporting-made-easy-with-the-right-ats), the product was not built for your regulatory environment. Key questions to ask: - How is candidate consent captured, logged and withdrawn? - Can the system produce EE and demographic reports out of the box? - Where is data hosted, and how is [POPIA compliance](https://www.graylink.biz/blog/popia-compliant-recruiting-what-you-need-to-know) maintained? For the full checklist, see our overview of [recruitment compliance management](https://www.graylink.biz/recruitment-compliance-management). #### 3. Candidate experience: does it work on a phone with limited data? Mobile-first design is essential for South African hiring because most applicants will apply from a phone. ICASA's State of the ICT Sector 2026 report found that [over 75% of South Africans accessed the internet via mobile data in 2024](https://www.engineeringnews.co.za/article/mobile-dominates-sa-internet-access-2026-05-01), while only 17.4% had a regular home connection. Long forms, mandatory CV uploads and desktop-only portals quietly filter out strong candidates before a recruiter sees them. The effect is sharpest in [non-desk and frontline hiring](https://www.graylink.biz/non-desk-worker-recruitment-software-graylink). Test it yourself. Apply for one of your own roles on a mid-range phone, using mobile data, and count the steps and minutes. Then check how candidates hear back: automated status updates and [WhatsApp-based screening](https://www.graylink.biz/chatbots-to-automate-recruitment-and-talent-processes) keep applicants engaged on a channel they already use. #### 4. Integration: will it connect to the rest of your HR stack? Your ATS must exchange data with your HRIS, payroll, assessment providers, background screening and job boards. Every gap between systems becomes manual work, and every manual step is a data-quality risk. Request the API documentation before you sign. A vendor that hesitates to share it is unlikely to move quickly on integrations after go-live. For a practical picture, see how [automated API workflows](https://www.graylink.biz/blog/recruitment-software-infrastructure-automated-api-workflows) connect recruitment systems and which [data exchange points](https://www.graylink.biz/data-exchange-and-integrations) matter most. Key questions to ask: - Which integrations are native, and which require middleware? - How does candidate data flow into onboarding and payroll? - Who maintains each integration when a connected system changes? #### 5. Automation and AI: does it remove real work? Judge automation by the admin hours it removes from high-volume tasks: screening, interview scheduling, bulk communication and document collection. Features that look clever in a demo but save no recruiter time should score low. Ask the vendor to quantify the time their [recruitment automation](https://www.graylink.biz/recruitment-workflow-automations) saves a customer similar to you, then confirm that figure with the customer directly. Be sceptical of autonomous AI claims: most recruitment tasks need [a dependable workflow rather than an AI agent](https://www.graylink.biz/blog/80-of-recruitment-ai-agents-should-be-workflows), and workflows are easier to audit. If AI weighs heavily in your decision, use our [AI recruitment vendor checklist](https://www.graylink.biz/blog/choosing-the-right-saas-partner-your-ai-recruitment-checklist) alongside this scorecard, and our [Recruitment and AI guide](https://www.graylink.biz/ai-recruitment) for the wider picture. #### 6. Reporting and analytics: can leadership see what matters? Time to hire, cost per hire, source effectiveness, pipeline health and EE metrics should be available on demand, not assembled by hand each quarter. Ask to see the reporting suite running on realistic data volumes. A dashboard that looks clean with 50 candidates may struggle with 50,000. Full audit trails matter too: when a hiring decision is challenged, structured data gives you a defensible record. See what strong [recruitment reporting and insights](https://www.graylink.biz/recruitment-reporting-insights) should cover. #### 7. Scalability: will it hold up at volume? If your campaigns attract thousands of applicants, ask for reference customers operating at that scale and test bulk actions during the trial. Performance under load, bulk processing and intelligent filtering decide whether your team manages volume or drowns in it. This matters most for [learnership programmes](https://www.graylink.biz/learnership-recruitment), [contact centre hiring](https://www.graylink.biz/call-centre-recruitment) and seasonal retail peaks, where applications spike in short windows. #### 8. Local support: who picks up the phone? Local support resolves problems faster because the team shares your time zone and understands your regulatory context. It also shortens escalation when something breaks during a live campaign. Ask about implementation timelines, training and what ongoing [customer success](https://www.graylink.biz/customer-success) includes. Then put the same questions to two of the vendor's existing customers. #### 9. Total cost of ownership: what will it really cost? Price every vendor over three years, not on the first invoice. Licence fees are only the visible cost. Implementation, integration work, training, configuration changes and the internal hours spent on workarounds all belong in the total. Use one formula for every vendor so the comparison is fair: 3-year TCO = (annual licence × 3) + implementation + integrations + training + change requests + (monthly workaround hours × hourly staff cost × 36) The last term is the one buyers skip, and it is often where a cheaper platform becomes the expensive one. To present these numbers to your executive team, use our [ATS ROI framework](https://www.graylink.biz/blog/maximising-ats-roi-a-strategic-framework-for-executive-approval). #### How do you run a fair ATS evaluation? Define your requirements first, then test every shortlisted vendor against the same workflow and the same scorecard. This five-step method keeps the comparison honest: 1. **Map one real workflow** from requisition to offer, including approvals. 2. **Shortlist three vendors** and give each the same workflow and scorecard. 3. **Run a sandbox trial** where recruiters and hiring managers complete the recruiter and candidate journeys themselves. 4. **Score each criterion** from 1 to 5, apply the weights and total the results. 5. **Call two reference customers** in your industry and at your hiring volume, then compare each vendor's score against its three-year TCO. #### What are the most common ATS evaluation mistakes? Four mistakes account for most poor ATS decisions: - **Buying on demo polish.** Scripted demos hide limitations. Insist on a trial with your own workflows. - **Leaving recruiters out.** They will use the system every day, so give them a vote in the scoring. - **Underweighting compliance.** Retrofitting EE and POPIA requirements after go-live is slow and costly. - **Assuming global means better.** International platforms are often built for different regulations, candidate behaviour and connectivity. #### Which ATS is right for South African employers? The right ATS is the one that scores highest on your weighted scorecard at a three-year cost you can justify. For many South African enterprises, [Neptune](https://www.graylink.biz/neptune-cloud-software-for-enterprise-recruitment-management) scores well against these criteria because it was built for local conditions: configurable workflows, EE and POPIA compliance by design, mobile-first candidate journeys and support from a team that knows the market. Whichever platform you shortlist, benchmark it against [South Africa's leading applicant tracking systems](https://www.graylink.biz/blog/best-applicant-tracking-systems-in-south-africa-according-to-local-experts) using the same scorecard. #### Frequently asked questions ##### What is the most important factor when choosing an ATS in South Africa? Configurability and compliance matter most. The system must fit your existing workflows and support POPIA and Employment Equity reporting without manual spreadsheets. ##### Is a global ATS better than a locally built one? Not necessarily. Global platforms often lack built-in EE reporting, low-data mobile applications and local support, so test them against South African requirements before you commit. ##### How do you calculate the total cost of ownership of an ATS? Add three years of licence fees to implementation, integrations, training, configuration changes and the staff hours spent on workarounds, then compare vendors on that total. [ATS](https://www.graylink.biz/blog/tag/ats), [Recruitment Software](https://www.graylink.biz/blog/tag/recruitment-software), [Applicant Tracking System](https://www.graylink.biz/blog/tag/applicant-tracking-system) ## Related posts [ATS](https://www.graylink.biz/blog/tag/ats), [AI](https://www.graylink.biz/blog/tag/ai), [Applicant Tracking System](https://www.graylink.biz/blog/tag/applicant-tracking-system), [AI Chatbot](https://www.graylink.biz/blog/tag/ai-chatbot) ## [South Africa’s Most Comprehensive Recruitment Platforms](https://www.graylink.biz/blog/south-africas-most-comprehensive-recruitment-platforms) [Azraa Jonkers](https://www.graylink.biz/blog/author/azraa-jonkers) 23 January, 2026 Overview In 2026, South African recruitment is no longer about choosing “an ATS” - it’s about... [Read more](https://www.graylink.biz/blog/south-africas-most-comprehensive-recruitment-platforms) [ATS](https://www.graylink.biz/blog/tag/ats), [Applicant Tracking System](https://www.graylink.biz/blog/tag/applicant-tracking-system), [Candidate Relationship Management](https://www.graylink.biz/blog/tag/candidate-relationship-management) ## [SaaS HR Infrastructure: A Modular Approach to Recruitment](https://www.graylink.biz/blog/saas-hr-infrastructure-a-modular-approach-to-recruitment) ![Picture of Mark Gray](https://www.graylink.biz/hs-fs/hubfs/Mark-Gray-graylink.png?width=50&name=Mark-Gray-graylink.png) [Mark Gray](https://www.graylink.biz/blog/author/mark-gray) 20 May, 2026 Overview The case for a single configurable HR platform is stronger than the market currently... [Read more](https://www.graylink.biz/blog/saas-hr-infrastructure-a-modular-approach-to-recruitment) [ATS](https://www.graylink.biz/blog/tag/ats), [AI](https://www.graylink.biz/blog/tag/ai), [Applicant Tracking System](https://www.graylink.biz/blog/tag/applicant-tracking-system) ## [Talent Fidelity: Combatting Recruitment Fraud with Smarter Assessments](https://www.graylink.biz/blog/talent-fidelity-combatting-recruitment-fraud-with-smarter-assessments) [Azraa Jonkers](https://www.graylink.biz/blog/author/azraa-jonkers) 7 July, 2025 Overview [Read more](https://www.graylink.biz/blog/talent-fidelity-combatting-recruitment-fraud-with-smarter-assessments) ![graylink\_logo\_white](https://www.graylink.biz/hs-fs/hubfs/graylink_logo_white_sansstrap_small.png?width=150&name=graylink_logo_white_sansstrap_small.png) ##### PRODUCTS ##### [Recruitment automation software](https://www.graylink.biz/products) ##### [Applicant tracking system](https://www.graylink.biz/neptune-cloud-software-for-enterprise-recruitment-management) ##### [Recruitment & talent chatbots](https://www.graylink.biz/chatbots-to-automate-recruitment-and-talent-processes) ##### [Neptune](https://www.graylink.biz/neptune-cloud-software-for-enterprise-recruitment-management) ##### [txthr](https://www.graylink.biz/chatbots-to-automate-recruitment-and-talent-processes)     ##### SOLUTIONS [Talent sourcing & engagement](https://www.graylink.biz/talent-sourcing-and-engagement?hsLang=en) [Recruitment process automation](https://www.graylink.biz/recruitment-workflow-automations?hsLang=en) [Recruitment compliance](https://www.graylink.biz/recruitment-compliance-management?hsLang=en) [Recruitment data & integrations](https://www.graylink.biz/recruitment-compliance-management-0?hsLang=en) [Recruitment reporting & insights](https://www.graylink.biz/recruitment-reporting-insights?hsLang=en) [Customer success](https://www.graylink.biz/customer-success?hsLang=en) [Recruitment and AI](https://www.graylink.biz/ai-recruitment) ##### COMPANY ##### [About graylink](https://www.graylink.biz/about) ##### [Join our team](https://www.graylink.biz/about#joinourteam) ##### [Privacy policy](https://www.graylink.biz/privacy-policy) ##### CONNECT ##### [Get in touch](https://www.graylink.biz/contact) ##### [Get demo](https://www.graylink.biz/getdemo) ##### [Future of talent blog](https://www.graylink.biz/blog) ###### --- Copyright © graylink Cloud Solutions (Pty) Ltd. All rights reserved. ```json { "@context" : "https://schema.org", "@type" : "BlogPosting", "author" : { "@type" : "Person", "name" : "Mark Gray", "url" : "https://www.graylink.biz/blog/author/mark-gray" }, "dateModified" : "2026-09-30T21:52:25.464Z", "datePublished" : "2026-06-12T11:57:40.000Z", "headline" : "Choosing the Right ATS: What to Evaluate Before Making a Decision", "mainEntityOfPage" : { "@id" : "https://www.graylink.biz/blog/choosing-the-right-ats-what-to-evaluate-before-making-a-decision", "@type" : "WebPage" }, "publisher" : { "@type" : "Organization", "logo" : { "@type" : "ImageObject", "url" : "https://www.graylink.biz/hubfs/graylink_logo_vector_colour.png" }, "name" : "graylink" } } ```